View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Which Jane combo to keep?
in reply to a message by whim
You know, I like Jane Alexandria Lilac best! It's a pretty name pairing a common-ish, 'plain' and very sensible name with fun middle names, and that's great. Lilac is unusual, but somehow not as whimsical as a lot of flower names, and Alexandria feels historic.I also like Jane Magnolia Frances. Frances is solid, like Jane, whilst Magnolia adds a touch of whimsy... at the same time, it's a very rare flower name.As an Ariadne, I'm biased about Jane Ariadne Lark. I don't think Ariadne flows with either of the names, and there are far prettier names out there besides. Plus, with shows like Atlantis (which I hate, sorry) on the Beeb at the minute, it might be one of these names which might suddenly start climbing the charts, like Hermione, Benedict and so forth... basically, fueled by fandom. I'd hope not, but you never know. I'm not a fan of Lark and I think it makes the ending of the combo quite harsh.Jane Primrose Adele... is my least fave. I think Primrose is faar to whimsical, far more so than Magnolia and leaps more so than Lilac (which has a sturdy sound and unusual ending and rarity on its side, whilst Primrose is far more girlish). It also has the taint of fandom. It's not ugly, but it's too sickly twee and girlish for my tastes. Adele... I just really don't like. I dislike most of the Ad- family of names, I just don't think they sound nice. But each to their own! Use it if -you- like it.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I've never seen the Atlantis series so I don't have that association when it comes to Ariadne but I can see your point. What it comes down to for me is that I like it's sound.Primrose is very much tied to it's literary association but I think it's adorable and can't help but love it for a middle name. I have a thing for flower names.Thank you for being so thorough!
vote up1