This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: anthony as a girls name?
in reply to a message by amy
Hm... listen to this.
I work at the human resources dept at school, and we have a person named Joe Anna Gonzalez. What do you think - is it a boy or a girl? (I can't tell you either).
So, unless you want your girl to encounter problems like this - yeah, name her Anthony.
vote up1vote down

Replies

anthony as a girls name?Sounds like Joe Anna's parents were experimenting! Obviously got the idea from Joanne...Out of curiosity...is Joe Anna of hispanic descent?? I think Anthony is definitely a boy's name...Ever thought of Antonia? Spanish for Anthony (Antonio). Cheers! :-D
vote up1vote down
The mystery Joe Anna was solvedOK, guys, here's the thing - Joe Anna is a guy (a rather "macho" one indeed :o). A note to Amy: Amy, Joe's (he goes by Joe only - what a surprise!) parents probably thought that there's nothing wrong with giving him a female middle name and he almost killed me out of anger that I got him into the computer as a girl. I am not saying this is right, but that's how society works: girls have girlish names. Period.
vote up1vote down
Well, Joanna is not such an unusual name, and if they spelled it Joe Anna, so what. However...Anthony, as well as Michael and Christopher, which I've heard people naming or considering to name their girls (I know of two female Michael's), are so inherently boy's names, to name a girl that is just insensitive to the social problems she will encounter.Andrea
vote up1vote down