View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Carmel as a male name?
Isn't it just a strongly marked Christian name? In which case in some cultures it can be used comfortably for both males and females. Maria/Marie is the most prominent example, but I would guess that Carmel could work in the same way.
vote up1vote down

Replies

This site is the first I've seen any specific connection with Mary and Carmel... I've always thought of it as Hebr. and therefore Jewish in its roots... though some Jewish names are also common among Christians.
vote up1vote down
Carmel and its derivates (Carmen) are used because of Our Lady of the Mount Carmel also known as Saint Mary of the Mount Carmel.
vote up1vote down
in that case it would be specifically Catholic... since most protestants aren't into following after the saints (and many have never heard of Mary of Mt. Carmel... We just think of it as a mtn. in Israel)... then others would hear it and think it sounds nice but have no idea of its association w/ any of the St. Mary series. As I said before, they'd just think of a mtn. in Israel.
vote up1vote down
Not specifically Catholic but also Orthodox. The use of Carmel as given name was started precisely as Catholic and Orthodox thing, if later some people hear the name and think that it is nice and use it in relation with the Mount Carmel or just as a random name, that is another thing, but the name in Western world is linked with Mary. I don't know if historically before 12th c. (the starting of the use of Carmel as Christian given name), among Jews or Muslims, Carmel was used as given name; I don't think so but I can be completely wrong here.It is the same with Sharon. The name is Biblical, because this one is the source, even if most of the people don't know that the name comes from the Bible and just use it because of the sound.People's ignorance doesn't modify the etymology or the history of the names.

This message was edited 3/12/2009, 5:09 AM

vote up1vote down
Same as Mary, therefore ... also originally Hebrew/Jewish! But they became popular among Christians for obvious reasons.
vote up1vote down