This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Mr Susan
I certainly see what you mean ... but what I don't understand is why parents in the 1980s (not the 1890s!) suddenly started making a statistically significant number of errors with their Elizabeth, Melissa and Sarah daughters. Had the forms changed and become confusing? Otherwise surely the 70s parents would have been doing the same kind of thing, and the 90s ones?Anyway, what you didn't say is probably as important as what you did: you haven't had direct personal experience of any boy named Lizzie, right? (And if right, then PHEW!)
vote up1vote down

Replies

It wouldn't be the parents making the errors, it would be the clerks at the Social Security administration who put the data into the computer. Entering the sex code into the computer probably originally involved typing in either a "1" or a "2", and it would have been very easy for a mistake to have been made. I have no idea why there would be more errors in the 1980s than in the 1970s or 1990s, but the accuracy in something like this might depend partly on how well trained the individuals involved were. It's quite possible that the 1980s data were actually entered first, with the 1970s data only being entered in later along with the 1990s while the system was becoming completely computerized. I certainly haven't had any direct personal experience of a boy named Lizzie; but then I hardly know every person in the USA! :)
vote up1vote down