This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: On constructed languages
Good question, I used the term loosely, I guess its a matter of degree. Of the three examples I use, I guess Esperanto is the only genuinely "constructed" out of scratch, using ingredients from other languages. For Hebrew, a better term would be "revived". As far a "Macedonian" is concerned, the language pre-existed as a Bulgarian dialect for ages. In 1944 it was named "Macedonian" out of the blue by Tito's government, and its grammar was codified so as to differente it from Bulgarian.
I agree that sign language is constructed. It is unfortunate that nobody thought of constructing an *international* SL. It is tragic that a user of American SL cannot communicate with a user of, say, Italian SL...
vote up1vote down

Replies

Pavlos:Didn't you read my reply?? There IS an International Sign Language, called ISL. Go to dww.deafworldweb.org/asl/ and click on More... under International Sign. Y
vote up1vote down
Aha :)
vote up1vote down