(bronze) Susan Roberts
1956 swimming - 4x100 m freestyle relay 
(silver/gold) Christina von Saltza (a.k.a. Susan)
1960 swimming - 100 m freestyle; swimming - 400 m freestyle; swimming - 4x100 m freestyle relay; swimming - 4x100 m medley relay 
(bronze) Susanne Shields (a.k.a. Susan)
1968 swimming - 100 m butterfly 
(silver/gold) Susan Pedersen
1968 swimming - 100 m freestyle; swimming - 200 m medley; swimming - 4x100 m freestyle relay; swimming - 4x100 m medley relay 
(silver) Susan Rojcewicz
1976 basketball 
(bronze) Susan Sloan
1976 swimming - 4x100 m medley relay 
(bronze) Susan Hearnshaw
1984 long jump 
(silver) Susan Rapp
1984 swimming - 200 m breaststroke 
(gold/silver/bronze) Susan O'Neill
1992; 1996; 2000 swimming - 200 m butterfly; swimming - 4x100 m medley relay; swimming - 200 m freestyle; swimming - 4x200 m freestyle relay 
(bronze) Susan Williams
2004 triathlon 
(gold/bronze/silver) Kim Rhode (a.k.a. Susan)
1996; 2000; 2004; 2008; 2012 shooting 
(gold) Susan Francia
2008; 2012 rowing 