View Message

[Opinions] Harlan and Roy
Both these names have been on my mind for a while. Roy was the name of my great uncle, short for Royal. He was quite a character. Harlan makes me think of the sci-fi author Harlan Ellison and a few people I know IRL. I've also come across the spelling Harlynn. Thoughts?https://quotidianpeace.wordpress.com/
vote up1

Replies

Hi! Both Roy and Harlan have a Medieval vibe in my opinion. Roy is so short but full of history and links that are Norman and Celtic. I love its regal meaning but also its rough form Ruadh that means "red".Harlan: as I live in Italy the only Harlan I came across is a fictional character... Sir Harlan of Pennytree, hedge knight created by George R.R. Martin in the 'Ice & Fire' Universe.I actually like them and I'd enjoy coming across one of them in the Anglosphere.

This message was edited 6/17/2023, 11:42 AM

vote up1
It's amazing to see how differently names are seen I didn't know a lot of Harlans until I moved to Midwest USA. I've met a handful now, all 80+.Roy is also fairly common in the US, 50+. It, too, seems to be more common in the Midwest.The idea that they are Medieval would never occur to me!
vote up1
Harlan doesn't happen where I live. Roy does: including one of my brothers-in-law, Roy Fraser LN. Scottish ancestry, and by a happy accident, he is also a redhead. I love both of his names.
vote up1
Roy is ok, don't really like Harlan
vote up1
Love Harlan, not crazy about Roy
vote up1
I also had a great uncle named Roy. He was in the same prison with Charles Manson, for a while.Anyway, I like Royal, and Roy has a certain charm. Harlan is very country bumpkin to me, because it just sounds that way. Not the worst thing in the world, I just picture a dude shucking corn when I hear it.
vote up1
That's why I like it. Harlan makes me think of a sun-beaten old farmer, calloused hands, leaning back in a chair with a cup of coffee. Old farmers are the best. Best jokes, best hugs, biggest hearts.
vote up1
Roy is fine, if bland and dated.Harlan Ellison is one association, but I can't not think of Harlan Crow at the moment. Not a fan of the name at all.
vote up1