Currently living in a city in Massachusetts. It really just depends where you are I mean, I don't think anything in New York
City will surprising, just too many people. That said, where I'm from, it would be a little off. People would definitely raise an eyebrow to it but it wouldn't be like OMG WHAT DID THEY DO TO THAT LITTLE GIRL?! Like I've met girls my age named Conner
, Seton, Tristyn, etc. the whole boy names on girls isn't foreign here and those were all suburban kids. But I have a city girl mindset, I've always lived in a city so I see them and raise an eyebrow but don't really care, I don't really know how the suburban community looks at them as a whole though.