View Message

Stella Jane is cute and spunky. I like it heaps better than SCARlett.

Stella Jane is nice. It feels a bit old fashioned to me, probably because Stella was my grandmother's name. But the name is currently on a popularity upswing, so I guess there are or at least soon will be plenty of little girls, teens, and young women named Stella.

---

I prefer Stella Jane to Scarlett Jane.

Scarlett will looks odd in certain places, whereas Stella will "fit in" better. Stella is a steadier classic. Scarlett looks more "downmarket" than Stella. If that sort of thing is a concern.

---

I do like Stella Jane. I do not prefer Scarlett Jane. Scarlett Joan I do like though! (unsolicited opinion sharing)

I like Stella Jane a lot! Certainly enough to use it, given enough daughters.

---

Scarlett doesn't please me at all. It seems dated but still show-offy.

I prefer Scarlett to Stella because Stella makes me think of stale bread. Jane seems like a filler probably because it's been used so much.

I like the combo. I don't think Scarlett Jane has the same ring to it. Go with Stella Jane.

Stella in my opinion is far superior to Scarlett, which just seems prickly and off-putting. Stella is punchy, feminine and Jane gives it a nice classic feel.

---

I do prefer Estella called Stella, but out of your choices, I'd definitely go with Stella.

---

Is Jane negotiable? It is sort of a filler middle name, unless you have a strong tie to it.

---

Others that might be more interesting with a classic feel...

---

Stella Caroline
Stella Penelope
Stella Josephine

I'll just give you some unsolicited advice first. Everyone can give you their opinions on a name, but in the end the choice is yours. My grandma hated my sister's name at first, but she eventually came around and loved both my sister and her name dearly.

---

Stella and Scarlett are both nice names. Personally, I prefer Stella. Jane is a bit filler for a middle name, which means it sounds nice with both first names even if it is super common. Definitely use it if it has meaning for you, though!

I much prefer Stella to Scarlett and Stella Jane works so much better than Scarlett Jane.

I don't mind the first names. And if they are your favourite names you should definitely use either of those. I prefer Scarlett to Stella.
I don't really like the middle name. Are you honoring someone? If not, do you like Jane or just like the flow of the combination?
Someone asked on a recent post which classic names we disliked the most, and my answer was Jane because it sounds boring. If I had to pick something that has a similar flow I'd go with Scarlett Wren. But that's just me. If you like Stella Jane, just go with it and your friends can name their own kids :)

---