View Message

Fast rise, fast fall
I normally don't link to my column here, but thought it would be appropriate this time since I mention behindthename.com in it:http://www.omaha.com/index.php?u_page=1219&u_sid=10644539This week's column is based on some academic research that got some media play earlier in the month.Like a lot of recent academic research on names, this was done by economists. I do sometimes wish the economists would stick to money matters and leave onomastics to the psychologists and sociologists. The guys who did this research did a lot of fancy statistical analysis to come up with a precise determination of how faster rising names also tend to fall faster. But then to get evidence for their theory that this is because parents avoid "fads", they use a questionnaire to expectant parents where they gathered their data from volunteers over Internet, with absolutely no discussion of how this makes it a nonrandom sample and so their results can't really be extrapolated to the entire population, as they try to do. These silly economists seem to believe that fancy statistical methods are more important than basic research design. Grumble, grumble. Too bad I didn't have room in the column to explain that better.
vote up1vote down

Replies

I didn't manage to find your column - looks like they just have the current articles available, or maybe I'm missing something.I participated in this research poll through a link from another name website. I don't recall whether the poll asked if I was an expectant parent. I hope they didn't assume that people who visit name websites are all expectant parents.
vote up1vote down
Hopefully the economists accounted for errors in the SSA data. Something like Christop is pretty hard to explain http://www.behindthename.com/top/search.php?terms=christop
vote up1vote down
Christop!A number of irreverent suggestions will be suppressed ... however, it does also suggest to me that ordinary people with big handwriting couldn't fit Christopher into a line or box on the forms, so did the best they could. Is there anything similar for other long names like Elizabeth? And did the format of the forms perhaps change, and then change back? Because I can't imagine how people in the 90s would have bigger handwriting than folks in other decades.
vote up1vote down
That's exactly it, the same thing happens for Elizabeth.
http://www.behindthename.com/top/search.php?terms=elizabetMaybe one state had difficulty in 1990.
vote up1vote down
CKE,
Is there a way to access your articles without linking the newspaper? I enjoy reading them but after a certain amount of time the link expires and I'm not able to view the article again.Thanks,
Tempestgirl
vote up1vote down
Does the link below work for you? It's one I have on my computer from February 2008 and is about the fourth article that was ever published:http://www.omaha.com/index.php?u_page=1219&u_sid=10267894Maybe you just have to register at the site for old links to work?
vote up1vote down