Madeline- with a
LINE at the end
Madeleine- same as
MadelineRosaline- rosa-leen
Caroline- cair-o-line
Emmeline- em-a-leen
I prefer
Claire to
Clare because
Clare looks like more of a surname to me. As for Shea/Shay/Shae I think
Shay looks masculine and
Shae looks childish and informal. I don't particularly like it, but out of the three
Shea is my favorite spelling.