Looking at your poll results
Josephine and
Gwendolyn wasn't that ill received, it was just skewed downward since there was only one 5. Basically what you got were 22 people saying yes to the set and 14 saying no or that they just weren't feeling it. Having people rate a name or set with numbers is pretty vague and you didn't give clear meanings to the numbers. Everyone rates differently. It's why I use a clearly worded scoring system instead of numbers that I "developed" over the course of about five years. I used to be a somewhat regular poster here but needed a break and then decided to start anew. lol But I digress...
I am not a huge fan of the sister set
Josephine and
Gwendolyn. The nicknames
Posy and
Gwen does strike my fancy though. It would be the one reason I'd be excited about the set. I just don't put
Josephine and
Gwendolyn in the same category of names. Also,
Gwendolyn is not an attractive name to me. I don't like it's shape.
Gwendolen appeals more.
http://www.babynames.com/namelist/9852886