View Message

Arthur

---

Arthur all the way, I just like the sound and feel and everything more. At this point, Percy reminds me of Percy Pig sweets.

Arthur. No contest!

---

Percy is way too stuffy and pretentious for my likely. Of course not as much as 'Percival' but it's still there.
Arthur is more natural, easy-going, less pompous.

Arthur

---

100% no contest.

---

Percy has alternate meanings in slang and I wouldn't do it to a child.

Percy

---

I used to love Arthur but that has diminished somewhat. They're both great names though and I think Percy is perfectly fine as a name in it's own right.

Percy definitely! I just don’t like Arthur, it’s so frumpy and lifeless. Percy is spunky and lively and can definitely work as a full name, no problem at all.

Arthur

---

I prefer the strong sound Arthur to the softer Percy. I do think, though, that Percy can stand on its own.

Percy

I like both Arthur and Percy.

---

Percy works fine as a name in itself, I feel, and I think I’d pick it over Arthur.

Percy is fine as an independent name. I would use it rather than Arthur because it is a family name and the name of an old family friend. Arthur carries a weight of once-and-future expectations with it that could be awkward. Good name, though.

Arthur -m-

---

Percy is pompous imo

I think Percy is good in itself. It's like Harry that way.

---

Percival / Percy over Arthur personally, but I think they're both too dated imo

Percy

I love them both, but if I had to choose one, I’d pick Arthur.

I love Arthur, though partly for sentimental reasons. But only if you don't call him Art. I think Percy works on its own. But I actively dislike it.

Neither