View Message

I really wish Indie Mae was short for something like India Mae or Indira Mae. Esme is nms but I wish it was spelled Esmee. Scarlett doesn't move me one way or the other. Evangeline Faith seems OTT religious to me because it's so obviously different from the names of her sisters. Still, it's my fave here and Evangeline offers great nn options.

That's a real mix of names I love and names I really dislike. I love Indie, Scarlett and Elizabeth. I really dislike Esme and Evangeline.

Lucky little Esme Jane! And I hope Evageline is a typo.

Indie Mae - I love Mae so much. I wish it was Indigo Mae. Indie feels incomplete and as if it's referring to Indian movies or something.
Esme Jane - short and sweet. Not my style, but they actually sound pretty good together.
Scarlett Elizabeth - wow, really heavy feeling. I feel like Scarlett could have been lightened up with Mae and Indie could have been made less flighty with Elizabeth or something.
Evangeline Faith - fine. Neither name does anything for me, so it's kind of forgettable.

---

Indie, Esme, Scarlett, and Evangeline don't sound cohesive at all. Oh well.

Oh wow, I've never heard of them but I love their names! All four first names have been favourites of mine at some point. Esme is a current top contender. The only thing that feels slightly off is that Esme Jane doesn't flow well for me, though both names are great.

It almost seems as though each parent chose the names for one set of twins given the differences in the styles. I like a few of the names individually (Mae, Esme, Jane, and Elizabeth) but I think they make a terrible set as a whole. I also dislike that two of the girls will have E as their first initial.