This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Is "Lilly" a nickname of Elizabeth?
I suppose that anyone can call themselves anything other than their given name, and claim it as their "nickname". You could just as easily have a child named "Elizabeth" with the nickname of "Sally".Most people, though, would not automatically associate the name "Lilly" with "Elizabeth" -- certainly not as easily as the nicknames "Liz" and Lizzie" are associated with Elizabeth.If you're talking about naming a child "Elizabeth" and then calling her "Lilly", she'll probably grow up having to explain to people all the time why her legal name differs from the name by which she is known.Why don't you simply name your child "Lilly Elizabeth"? Or even "Lily Elizabeth", as the flower "lily" is correctly spelled with one "l".Even "Lilibeth" or "Lilybeth" are pretty names for a girl.-- Nanaea
vote up1vote down

Replies

I don't really see what's so unusual about using Lilly as a nickname for Elizabeth when both Libby and Bess can be nicknames. I don't necessarily think they seem like logical nicknames. I don't know if you watched it while it was on, but Sela Ward played a character named Lily on "Once and Again" and her given name was supposed to be Elizabeth. So, at least one other person had the same idea as you. I personally loved the nickname Winnie but hated the names it was short for, either Winifred or Edwina, and wanted to used it for Gwendolyn. When I tried to find out through an internet searc if you could use Winnie as a nickname for Gwendolyn, I was surprised to see that another tv show had the same idea. Evidently, Winnie on "The Wonder Years" was really a Gwendolyn. Who knew? Anyways, getting back to Lilly. I think it's a beautiful name on it's own or as a nickname, and personally, I prefer Lilly with 2 l's even though the flower is spelled with one l. It just seems more like a name. I can't explain it. After all, Lillian is spelled most often with 2 l's so why couldn't Lilly be spelled with 2 also? You could even spell it Lillie if you wanted to get creative. As far as it being a strange nickname for Elizabeth, look at Sarah. A nickname for Sarah is actually Sally and I would never have made the connection had I not read it in many baby name books.
vote up1vote down
Thanks Nanae... Good point.
vote up1vote down