New Post
Search
Help
ArchivesRe: About the gender and the usage of the name Gabby
in reply to a message by LeoBeyene
Hi Leo,
Your passion for unisex names is evident and admirable. There are indeed examples of male Gabbys. However, when adding usages and genders my goal is NOT to be exhaustive. There needs to be a balance between concise and exhaustive, otherwise that data loses value. Note also that the forebears.io source is not great for determining the usage of diminutives. It is likely that a significant percentage of the women named Gabrielle, Gabriella, etc. in the ESW are also known as Gabby.
You can make a case that Gabby should be listed as Filipino. However, there are likely many more names that should be added to the under-researched Filipino category first. If you want me to add Filipino usage JUST so the name shows as unisex, then I cannot get behind this.
You can submit a correction for Gabby with a suggestion that Filipino should be added. Note you only need to submit a correction once, not 10 times. The message boards are not a good place to request corrections.
One last thing of note: 2 of the 3 male Gabbys you cited as examples are not Gabriels. They acquired their nicknames for other reasons (as described in their Wikipedia articles). Just thought that was interesting.
Mike
Your passion for unisex names is evident and admirable. There are indeed examples of male Gabbys. However, when adding usages and genders my goal is NOT to be exhaustive. There needs to be a balance between concise and exhaustive, otherwise that data loses value. Note also that the forebears.io source is not great for determining the usage of diminutives. It is likely that a significant percentage of the women named Gabrielle, Gabriella, etc. in the ESW are also known as Gabby.
You can make a case that Gabby should be listed as Filipino. However, there are likely many more names that should be added to the under-researched Filipino category first. If you want me to add Filipino usage JUST so the name shows as unisex, then I cannot get behind this.
You can submit a correction for Gabby with a suggestion that Filipino should be added. Note you only need to submit a correction once, not 10 times. The message boards are not a good place to request corrections.
One last thing of note: 2 of the 3 male Gabbys you cited as examples are not Gabriels. They acquired their nicknames for other reasons (as described in their Wikipedia articles). Just thought that was interesting.
Mike
2
Replies
Well... Okay! Thank you for the heads up, and thank you for praising me about my passion for Unisex names! 😉
The reasoning is very elaborate and well-detailed. I never said I want you to make the name Unisex again, I was just asking you a reason why for this change.
Thank you for also telling me about the rules of submitting corrections, I will try to remember this next time!
Leo Beyene!
The reasoning is very elaborate and well-detailed. I never said I want you to make the name Unisex again, I was just asking you a reason why for this change.
Thank you for also telling me about the rules of submitting corrections, I will try to remember this next time!
Leo Beyene!
This message was edited 3/7/2024, 2:16 PM
1