I like it. Are you asking for a pitch? I hope so ...
I don't think it's any more ingratiating than any other good-noun name. I think, say,
Chase and
Grayson and
Ruby and
Willow sound more warm-ingratiating to me than
River.
River is a little weird, Hollywoody and try-to-be-elfish, like all fashionable word-names are - like
Ivy,
Nova,
Everly, even
Violet - but not annoyingly so, it's not purple like Evolet or Valor or Evening or Ever or Vesper. And it's trendy and vaguely surnamey, similar to, but not as much as, something like
Riley or
Sawyer or
Avery, or even
Hunter or
Everett (which I like).
I just feel like the nature-image overpowers everything else about it - it's like
Summer, just sort of appealing at an instinctive level because like, sunshine and flowing water, they're essential to life. Like with
Summer, I'm a little confused about why it didn't become a name a long time ago... along with the likes of
Garnet,
Forest,
Grover,
Clover,
Easter,
Fern,
Dale,
Myrtle,
Ginger ...
River would sorta fit with them, in my mind. Well, it would, if it did. As it is, it sounds modern like
Griffin or
Kai... and I like that too.
- mirfak