View Message

[Opinions] Clara, Colleen, & Mary
Clara Bow, Colleen Moore, and Mary Pickford inspired this thread. I have a thing for 1920's movie stars. So, WDYT? Willoughby wolloughby willina, an elephant sat on Billina.
Willoughby wolloughby wirfak, an elephant sat on Mirfak.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Where's Louise Brooks?I like Clara a lot, but of all the "Clare" names my favorite would probably be Clarice / Clarisse (the latter spelling is used in "Fahrenheit 451").Colleen has always seemed "dated" to me, but I have no doubt it will find popularity with the current hipster generation.Mary Pickford is amazing, but the name Mary itself is so, so overdone. So many Marys in every generation - even Marie would be 10x better!I'm surprised Louise Brooks wasn't in the OP, though. I personally dislike the "wheeze" ending, but a lot of people find Louise quite charming (I prefer Louisa).
vote up1
Love Clara and Mary. Colleen seems dated and frumpy to me.
vote up1
Clara - love this name; it's one of my faves.
Colleen - like this name, and so did my parents; if I'd ever had a younger sister, she would have been Colleen.
Mary - mostly indifferent to this name. It just feels a bit plain and overdone.

This message was edited 8/13/2015, 7:51 PM

vote up1
I like Clara, Colleen is dowdy, Mary's ok but a bit boring.
vote up1
Clara is nice and will age well. Colleen is unappealing, ugly and dated imo, sorry. Mary is classic, beautiful and timeless, I love it.
vote up1
I really like them all together, though individually I'm only fond of Clara. Clara Colleen Mary would be a great combo, or they sound like a cool trio of sisters. There's a saucy innocence about them.

This message was edited 8/12/2015, 6:20 PM

vote up1
Clara's my second favorite name, only just losing out to Annabel. Colleen is one of those names that's just... there. I've never had strong feelings one way or the other toward it. *shrug* It's a name.Mary's a family name (my grandmother is Mary, and my sister is Mary-Jo) as well as the name of a good friend, so I'm fond of it.
vote up1
Clara and Mary are beautiful, classy names. Colleen irks me with its fake Irish-ness. I mean, would you name your child Girl?
vote up1
I like Mary and Colleen. I can't get on board with Clara because it just makes me think of Clara Potts.
vote up1
I want to like Clara because of its nineteenth century quaintness. But I can't help it, it makes me think of a cow. It's funny that Miss Bow had such an un-sexy name.I don't like Colleen because it's faux Irish.And Mary, we all know I despise Mary because it's so generic. Far too generic to make one automatically think of Miss Pickford.
vote up1
If you do not mind my question - why is the name Mary so generic? I am only curious as to why a name as old as Mary (and any derivatives) is thought to be generic. Thanks
vote up1
Because it was so common for centuries. It couldn't be generic if it weren't old, which is not to say that all old names are generic. It's a combination of overuse and that overuse being spread over a very long time. I also think that John is generic.Of course, this is just my opinion.
vote up1
Colleen is the least blah of the trio, but even it is kind of dull and glum. Clara is kind of seen as stylish in some circles now, and Mary might not be popular anymore but it's everywhere and totally forgettable. A little Colleen would stand out for sure.
vote up1
I am not really into any of them. Of the three Clara would be my favorite.
vote up1
Clara's one of my favorites
Mary is nice
I don't like Colleen
vote up1
I like all three, and I think they would make a darling sister set.
vote up1
They would make a great sibset, wouldn't they? If I ever have triplet girls, I'll go this route.
vote up1