View Message

[Facts] Anthony
Or, of course, Antony.I've often seen the false etymology of "priceless" given as the "Latin" origin of Antonius. Where does it come from? My Latin's pretty rusty, but I can't think of any way "priceless" could possibly work.Thanks!
vote up1vote down

Replies

The Latin word for priceless is "inaestimabilis", so it's highly unlikely that Anthony means "priceless". I've noticed that baby name books often try to appeal to parents and like to make up meanings as opposed to giving out the actual meaning.Sometimes confusion with other names or words leads to false etymologies - that's probably why many people associate Anthony with the meaning "flower". There are numerous legitimate Greek names with the element anthos, such as, Anthea, Anthousa, Anthimos, Chrysanthe, Melanthe, etc.This is a good article that explains why baby name books are often unreliable: http://www.namenerds.com/uucn/advice/namebook.html
vote up1vote down
This is sort of a speculative half-answer. The |-ius| suffix usually means "son of..." If this is true for this name, it could mean "son of Antonus." The expected descendants of that name would be Antono, Antone & Anton. These are said to be variants of Antonius, but are more likely variants of its predecessor, like Julus vs. Julius, etc.Restated, "Antonus" may yield a better lead for this etymology.
vote up1vote down
I checked several sources, and the closest I can find is "tonus," meaning "sound."
vote up1vote down
|An-| could be some kind of prefix...
vote up1vote down
"An" in Latin means "or" or "whether."
vote up1vote down
Right. But my subsequent search for the etymology of the name "Anton, son of Heracles" or then "Antonus, son of Hercules" was not successful, and neither did it lead to a hint about the origin of the "priceless" folk etymology.Some more speculations can be found here:
http://forum.wordreference.com/threads/origin-of-the-name-antonia-antonio.2375252/
vote up1vote down
Even though there is more meaning to be had, descendancy from a legendary figure may have been the main point of pride. That seems to be the case for Julius, son of Julus.
vote up1vote down
I checked by googling around for quite some time: The info itself is around everywhere - I saw it in English, in German, and in French. I saw it in books, with the help of Google Books search.But nowhere any source for it, nor any indication which Latin word could be behind it.The only interesting tidbit that I could come up with: The oldest book with the "priceless" meaning in it that I found is from 1967:
https://books.google.ch/books?id=94psAAAAMAAJSo this certainly predates the usual baby names websites copy-and-paste nonsense that is often the source of questionable meanings.
vote up1vote down
Funnily enough, I first came across it in a children's book that was written by two English schoolgirls in the 1930s. A relative of mine gave me her very old copy as a curiosity. In it, there's a character named Anthony and one of his sisters buys a booklet with name meanings: Bridget and Frances are mentioned, with accurate derivations, and then there's this interesting dialogue: "What's Anthony?" "Priceless." "Shh, don't make jokes!"I strongly doubt that a bit of random, giggly dialogue in a happy-kids-on-horseriding-holiday book long ago could have sparked a false etymology so they must, surely, have found it somewhere.
vote up1vote down
The Far-Distant Oxus! That's one of my favorites, and yes, I remember that dialogue.
vote up1vote down
OT Anneza & ClaudiaDid either of you ever read the sequels? I am still curious about Maurice. :)
vote up1vote down
All of them! And Crowns, which was different and excellent in a very strange way - don't remember much about it, except the effect it had.When in later life I started reading Golden Age detective fiction, Albert Campion reminded me rather of Maurice. Both had very distinguished connections that they'd rather nobody knew about! So I rather assume royalty, perhaps at a couple of removes!
vote up1vote down
From this site:"Meaning & History
English form of the Roman family name Antonius, which is of unknown Etruscan origin.
...
It has been commonly (but incorrectly) associated with Greek ανθος (anthos) "flower", which resulted in the addition of the h to this spelling in the 17th century."
vote up1vote down
Not what I asked at all, but thanks anyway.
vote up1vote down
My research on this issue revealed that FN Anthony/Antony is derived from the Roman name sexes Antonius and an ancient Roman "nomen gentile" resp. gender name, meaning unknown. English variant/form Anthony
French variant/form Antoine
Italian variant/form Antonio/Antonello
German variant/form Anton/Antonius
Hungarian variant/form Antal
Czech variant/form Antonin
Slavic variant/form Ante/Antek Bye
vote up1vote down
Not what I asked at all, but thanks anyway.
vote up1vote down