View Message

[Opinions] Joy or Joyce
Which do you prefer? I'm leaning towards Joyce recently, it feels less frilly than Joy and has less of the "but what if she will be clinically depressed?" problem.- Formerly known as Murasaki-Some thoughts and recipeshttp://italianlaowaigirl.blogspot.com/http://lagerusalemmecucinata.blogspot.com/
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Ohhhh I really like both but probably lean towards Joyce more for similar reasons to you
vote up1
Joy...Clean simple virtue name. It has a jewel like quality. I just think of the emotion.Joyce is more dated, mom age, and sounds more musty/mushy. Also i think of James Joyce.

This message was edited 10/1/2016, 12:49 AM

vote up1
I like Joy better.
vote up1
I don't like Joyce. It comes out of the mouth weird. It's like someone took a perfectly good name and decided to try to make it sound awful with as little chances as possible.
vote up1
Joy, definitely. Joyce sounds like a frumpy sixty-year-old woman with a really bad perm and too much perfume and a house full of glass figurines.
vote up1
I love both Joy and Joyce.Joyce a little more at the moment because of Netflix show 'Stranger Things', where Winona Ryder's character is named Joyce and I've fallen for both the show and her character.It could always be Joyce, with the option of Joy should a nickname ever come into question. That's how I think of it. :)

This message was edited 9/28/2016, 6:56 AM

vote up1
Joyce. It has more... closure.Plus, I feel like every movie I've seen with someone named Joy is very depressing? Mostly just Room and Inside Out.
vote up1
I've only read "Room" the book, where she doesn't have a name. Anyway, Joy is also the name of CS Lewis' wife who died, and appears in "Shadowlands", which is defintely a depressing association.
vote up1
Inside OutYou found it depressing? How?!
vote up1
The main character was like suffering from depression and I cried a lot both times I watched it? Also, Bing-Bong!
vote up1
It did make me cry. But I didn't find it depressing, just moving really. I loved itBing Bong though... :-(
vote up1
I loved it too, but I guess the word I was looking for was "heavy".
vote up1
Inside Out made me cry too. I love that movie, but it did make me bawl. Just like Up did!!
vote up1
I've honestly never cried as much as when I went to see UP
vote up1
Where I am from, Joyce is a grandmother name, which makes it perfect for a comeback right now. It's in the same vein as the uber-chic Evelyn imo. Though, I do know of some "mom-age" Joyces... so it might still be frumpy-dated for some. As for me, I have always preferred Joyce because it seems more complete than Joy. For some reason, I also think Joyce takes away some of the in-your-face girlishness out of Joyce. Joy is part of my own name, and I like it. I just find it overly simple sometimes.
vote up1
Joy seems a very simple name to me - not at all frilly. Also, people with certain kinds of depression experience all their emotions very intensely - including the ones we think of as 'good', such as joy. So I don't see the problem there, any more than calling a son - who could turn out to be a bit of a loser - 'Victor'.I'll admit I don't like the sound of Joy all that much, but of the two I'd pick itJoyce I actually hate. I don't like the juicy sound of it. For a female it seems fancified, along the lines of adding an 'e' to single syllable names just to be really sure they're feminine enough. And even so, Joyce is more a male name to me
vote up1
I had an aunt Joyce, also a cousin (her daughter), so I'm disposed to like the name. (My cousin was always called Joycey, to mark the difference between mother and daughter.)
Although my mother's family is prone to adding an"ie" or "y" onto every name if possible.Joy is good too, though;I've known a couple. One was kind of the embodiement of the name, with curly black hair and a bouncy personality, the other was just an ordinary girl.
vote up1
I agree with the others. Joy seems less frumpy and dated. Disclaimer: I do love Joy enough to use so I'm not totally objective here. ;-)
vote up1
I prefer Joy as Joyce just seems frumpy to me. I don't love Joy, though.It's interesting that Joyce was a medieval name, died out and became just about obsolete, and then made this roaring comeback, though.
vote up1
I like Joy better. Joyce sounds like the name of a crabby middle-aged woman.
vote up1