This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Mehitabel, or ...?
No, I haven't; I was looking for something else entirely.Murdo = Murder, eh? That's really funny. And I suppose people's usual inhibitions about arguing with an expert with a clipboard would kick in, so they wouldn't check or query. But the English seem to have learnt: I had a son in England when my husband was a student there (do you call them graduate students? We say 'postgraduate'), and when I registered his birth I had to spell his names (Peter David Alastair) really slowly and then check the transcription, and then check again once it had all been done in elegant calligraphy! Peter? David? Alastair is more problematic ... but they really took it all very seriously, which I was happy about.All the best
vote up1vote down

Replies

MurdoYes, it's certainly possible that sometimes people wouldn't argue with the census taker. But as most of these records were in the 19th century, many of the parents were probably illiterate and so had no way of knowing what the "correct" spelling of their own child's name was. :)
vote up1vote down
How very nice, then, that they were willing to branch out and move away from mainstream names when naming their children, not letting a lack of schooling stand in their way. I like it!
vote up1vote down