Replies

Joni is too close to Johnny for me. I don't mind Joan. Much better than Jane. In old records, I have seen it spelled Jone. Mostly from England in the middle ages.
vote up1vote down
Joni is too close to Johnny for me. I don't mind Joan. Much better than Jane. In old records, I have seen it spelled Jone. Mostly from England in the middle ages.
vote up1vote down
It's fascinating that Joan Crawford was chosen as a more sexy / alluring / "Hollywood-brand" name than Lucille LeSueur. Today it would be the other way around! Joan Crawford feels so stodgy and Lucille LeSueur more romantic.
vote up2vote down
Just the word Crawford makes me about nauseated. I wouldn't call Joan sexy either but hey, who knows what those Hollywood nuts were thinking. I do think her real name was much better. I think LeSueur would have been much less of an issue than some might think. While most people in America don't speak French, it isn't exactly unheard of and a lot of places have French names. English also borrows a good many French words. The French have always been considered posh here too. Probably more so in the time of Joan Crawford.
vote up1vote down
I really don't think LeSueur would be a good surname for an actress even today. One reason Crawford wanted to get rid of it was because most Americans when looking at it would tend to pronounce it as "Le Sewer", which definitely is not a romantic image. :)
vote up3vote down
Interesting as always. You fitted a lot of information into a small space; I would have liked to see when Joanna and Joanne entered the charts, and why.
vote up4vote down
Thanks -- it is really a small number of words to discuss the history of a name that's been used for centuries. This particular column is actually a bit longer than normal -- they let me go about 40 words over my limit just so I could include the paragraph about the Hispanic male name Joan. :)
vote up3vote down
I actually prefer Joan on boys. Because it sounds like Joe but with an N. I prefer the Spanish pronunciation as well. Zho-ahn. Its handsome.

This message was edited 11/8/2021, 9:38 AM

vote up2vote down