I like all three names and in fact have all three names in my family tree.
Elijah and
Elisha are brothers along with sisters
Elizabeth and
Eliza (yes I know). I always wondered what their second child did wrong as his names starts with a C. I do think though that any boy called
Elisha now would likely get teased due to the popularity of
Alicia for girls. I pronounce them differently though as I pronounce
Alicia Alice-ee-a unless told otherwise.
Don’t take criticism from someone you wouldn’t take advice from