I've only heard of the song, "
Polly, put the kettle on," so this poem is quite intriguing! For my sibset (with middle names!), regarding 1893 (which is when the poem was apparently written), here is what I would choose:
Phoebe SusannahDorothy "
Dolly"
AbigailRhoda ElsiePolly CoraFrances "
Frannie"
Tillie