View Message

[Opinions] Emily or Lily
My hubby and I are disagreeing on a name. He wants Lily and I want Emmaline. I'm trying to compromise and go with Emily. He isn't totally budged though. So here are the full names and please tell me what you think.Emily Isobella MahriLily Isobella MahriThe last name is Hodges BTW.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I love the name Lily, but I think that Emily sounds better with the middle names you already have. However, I do think that Lily sounds better with your surname.Have you considered Lillian, Liliana, or Emilia?
vote up1
Thanks to everyone for their responses!! :) tried to make sure I replied to everyone but this site works weird on my phone :(
vote up1
Emmaline, Emily, and Lily all have good points. If you hadn't already picked out a middle name I was going to suggest Lily Emmaline (a bit of a tongue twister maybe).
vote up1
Emily Isobella Mahri is my pick.
vote up1
vote up1
Emily.I just like it more.
vote up1
I vote for Lily. Lily Hodges is adorable.
vote up1
EmilyLily isn't bad, but Emily is a much stronger name.
Emily Hodges also sounds better than Lily Hodges.Personally, I'd much rather be an Emily than a Lily. Lily is one of the weakest names I know.What do you guys think of Lilian, Liliana, or Lillian? He could call her Lily and you wouldn't have to.
vote up1
I think Emily is lovely
vote up1
Lily. Emily is very bland in comparison, and doesn't sound great with Isobella.Could you do Lily Emmaline Mahri?
vote up1
Emily!I vote for the classic Emily all the way! Though currently much too popular for my tastes, it remains one of those rare, stripped-down three-syllable gems with unassailable substance, partially due to the literary Dickinson and Bronte associations.In my mind, neither Lily or Emmaline approach the loveliness of Emily. Nor do they age so well.

Cheers!-S
vote up1
Hi !!!I prefer...
Emily Isobella Mahri (Hodges)I think it is a great compromise...But...Mahri?
It is the first time that I hear it.Byeeeeeeeeeee
vote up1
Mahri is an old Scottish version of Marie. It's a family name passed down through my mom's side.
I also like Emily :)
vote up1
Emmaline, Emily, and Lily all go great with your combo. You can't really go wrong. Maybe you could both rank all three, and see if you can reach a compromise that way, or maybe you can convince DH that Lily can be a nn for Emily.
vote up1
Honestly? They're both pretty worn out by this point. I also think you and the hubs should ditch them both since you can't decide and start over. You both should love Baby's name. Still, if you're committed to one of these, I'd go with Lily. I also agree with another poster about changing Isobella to Isabella. While I love the Scottish Isobel, Isobella just looks strange to me.
vote up1
Emily is so boring. I prefer Lily.
vote up1
Ditch them both and try to find something less usual. They are both Bore City at this point, irrespective of whether I like them or not.
vote up1
I much prefer Lily to Emily, but Emily would work in your situation.
vote up1
I like both Lily and Emmaline but I really dont like Emily. I think Lily Isobella Mahri is cute :)
I know two people called Lily: Lily Mae and Lily Sassafras, im not sure if I like the Sassafras though...
Anyway good luck :)
vote up1
Lily!I definitely prefer Lily over Emily or Emmaline. Emily is one of those names that have gotten into fashion a few years ago. The trend seems to be over now but there are SO many Emilys out there. Lily sure is popular, too, but this has always been the case. It's a very classy name with history. I dislike Isobella because it looks misspelled. What about Lily Isabella?
I know, this is a very popular variant, but still pretty.
vote up1
Isobella and Mahri are both family names so I won't be changing those.
Thank you for responding :)
vote up1
I prefer Emily. Lily is too cutesy for my taste. I could tolerate it as a nickname, but as a full name I just don't like it. Emily isn't really my taste either, but it's better Lily. I'm with you on this one, Emmaline or (even better) Emmeline is much nicer. Emily Isobella Mahri is a nice combo, though the Isobella spelling looks a bit unnecessarily complicated.
vote up1
Isobella is a family name so I won't be changing the spelling. But I agree that Emmaline and also Emmeline are great :)
vote up1