View Message

[Opinions] Lily, Maia or Eilonwy? (more)
Just wondering which one of my top favorites for a girl you would choose and why:Lily
Eilonwy
Maia (MAH-ya or MY-ah, when said in everyday talk and sentences they sound the exact same to me)Please rate my list: https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/6232
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Maia.Lily is passé. And I have no idea how to pronounce Eilonwy and suspect some other people wouldn’t either. It is awkward looking, much prefer Elowen.

This message was edited 5/21/2021, 1:47 PM

vote up1
Eilonwy - if my husband were enthused about it and helped talk me into it. Who me, Welsh? No - but I don't really give a damn.
If I got flak over it from her dad, Maia instead. A great name, simple, strong and warm.Lily is very pretty, but I don't think it sounds like a name for an adult, and I wouldn't really like being named it, so it would not be on my list for a daughter. It's kind of aggressively maidenish, to me.
vote up1
Lily is my favorite girl name. If I ever had a daughter, this would be her name.I really like Eilonwy, but I don’t think I could be brave enough to use it as a first name.I’m not crazy about Maia or any other similar names like May, Mae or Maya.
vote up1
Lily because it seems the most practical and cute
vote up1
I dislike Lily for its repeated sounds like baby-babble, its slimy feel in the mouth, its reference to drooping white flowers associated with funerals ...
I like Eilonwy, but I don't consider it usable as a fn outside Wales. As a mn, yes!
I like Maia a lot. May is a family name, but it doesn't appeal to me half as much as Maia; I like the Latin meaning, and especially the little German TV bee!
vote up1
Maia. Lilly is too frilly and Eilowny just looks like random letters thrown together to me.
vote up1
Eilonwy for sure. It's the weirdest one, and I'm into that. Eilonwy is awesome.
vote up1
Lily. It’s so timeless and classic and just beautiful. Sure it’s really popular, but that’s because it’s gorgeous, wearable and doesn’t date.
vote up1
They are all pretty.
I'd choose...1) Lily (even though everyone seems to be tired of it)
or
2) Maia (by the way, I like the spelling)
3) Eilonwy (which do you prefer ie-LON-wee or ay-LON-wee?)
vote up1
I think ie-LON-wee because it matches the German pronunciation so it will work better in Germany. But I like both.
vote up2
Lily, more traditional, well known, easy to spell and pronounce
vote up1