It completely depends on the surname. With certain surnames I tried with it I perefered
Oscar and for others I prefered
Gabriel. They both go well with
Jonathan but most names do.
Without knowing the surname this what I have to say. Even though I personally prefer
Gabriel to
Oscar, I'm leaning slightly towards
Oscar since
Jonathan is so common and popular. In the US
Gabriel is pretty popular at the moment but I forget if you are in the US. I'm feeling like you aren't in the US though.
Is
Jonathan more your choice or your DH's? I know
Gabriel is more your choice and
Oscar is more your DH's. If
Jonathan is more your favorite then maybe go for
Oscar and if
Jonathan is more your DH's favorite then maybe go for
Gabriel. Has the naming of your other children been fairly equal or has one of you slightly dominated so far? Because I personally like the naming process to be as equal as possible, but that's just me.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My Favorite Names:
Serafina,
Fiona,
Luna,
Stella,
Artemis,
Callisto,
Augustine,
Genevieve,
Freya,
Juno,
Andromeda,
Frieda,
Deirdre,
Hazel,
Miranda and
Leona.
Keiran,
Magnus,
Arthur,
Teagan,
Cedric,
Taliesin,
Theron,
Quinn,
Fionn,
Rowan,
Julian, Fenris,
Gavin,
Xavier,
Perseus,
Damien and Cygnus