View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Which names don't 'go'?
I'm commenting on how I think they match with Romilly ... whether I think most sisters named Romilly and ___ would feel like they both got equally good names ... not on whether I like the names.
For ones I say they work ok, that's for people called by the full names - assume it's qualified by whether any nicknames work together too.
Romilly is not a fave of mine but it's alright. I think it sounds pretty dominant, but also a little frilly and glamorous, and a sister should have a name that can compete with it on those fields.Adeline - eh, plain. Adelina maybe
Agnes - doesn't work. Agnes makes Romilly seem silly
Alexandrine - works ok
Anastasia - ok
Anouk - ok
Arabella - ok
Araminta - ok
Beatrice - eh ... Beatrice seems so much more buttoned up than Romilly.
Bronwen - ok. I don't mind the similar sound
Camille - I do sort of mind the similarity
Cecily - cute match.
Cosima - nah, too ugly.
Daphne - hmm ok but Daphne is much less serious than Romilly
Edith - ok
Eleanora - clash.
Eliza - clashy
Elowen - okay
Eugenia / Eugenie - odd
Eulalia / Eulalie - ok
Florence - ok
Frances - eh. glamor differential
Gaia - neat mix
Georgiana - outfrills Romilly too much
Guinevere - weird style clash
Gwen - odd but ok. Gwendolen better
Harriet - interesting contrast, but glamor differential too high to be fair.
Hebe - way too ugly.
Hedwig - worse!
Helena - ok
Hermione - neat mix
Hero - no
Ianthe - neat mix
Isadora (it's spelled Isidora. "Isadora" is like "Romally" ;-P) - ok
Josephine - too buttoned
Juniper - ok
Juno - ok
Katharine - no, too boring
Kerensa - good
Keturah - clashy
Linnéa - ok
Margot - ok
Marguerite - barely ok
Marina - ok
May - big glamor differential
Milena - ok
Miriam - clash
Nora - no. Romilly makes Nora seem weak.
Olympia - I like Olympia but this is too unequal
Ophelia - see Olympia
Penelope - clash
Philippa - ok
Philomena - not liking the similar sound, it makes them sound clunky
Sybil - ok... ish. maybe too plain
Tempest - ok
Thisbe - neat
Viola - eh... maybe.
Vivienne - ok
Wilhelmina - too staid
Winifred - too ugly
Wren - hm. ok. interesting mix
Zelda - nope- mirfak
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Quoteit's spelled Isidora. "Isadora" is like "Romally"
Isadora has been used since the 19th century at least, though, so I think it's fairly legitimate. More legitimate than Romilly, even, and Isidora changes the pronunciation for me. Thank you, though!
vote up1
Yeah, it's legitimate, in the same way that Mckayla will be legitimate in 100 years.
Sorry, I just hate it =( nothing personal

This message was edited 10/18/2014, 11:47 AM

vote up1
Ah, well, never mind :)
vote up1