View Message

[Opinions] Are these names appropriate?
I have recently came to enjoy the names Chaya, Lev, and Alona, but they are exclusively Jewish. Would they be appropriate on a non Jewish character?

Replies

Chaya strikes me as a bit out of left field for a non-Jewish character. Alona looks like a variant of Alana, which is pretty widely applicable. I think Lev is fine.
As a Jewish person myself, I think Chaya is inappropriate on a non-Jewish character, but the other two are fine. Alona isn’t even known as a Jewish name; it just looks trendy.

This message was edited 4/28/2025, 5:20 PM

Alona is a common name in Israel.
Then perhaps it depends on whether you anticipate your readers to be largely from Israel.
I read a jewish book about a sweet girl named Chaya. I also like Lev. Alona is not my favorite simply because it sounds just like "alone."
For a non-jewish character? I think Lev could work.
Lev in also popular in Russia, Ukraine, and Armenia. The reason I thought Chaya would be OK as it sounds like Maya which is excepted for Americans. People in America are also naming their kids Cohen, so I don't know if you would be frowned upon for Chaya, but i wouldn't use it.
No one I can think of would frown upon Chaya. I am from the US and I think it's a beautiful name.
I wouldn't expect everyone with a Hebrew name to be Jewish. The level of exposure a non-Jewish person (or character) has to various Hebrew names would depend on a variety of factors.I personally would not feel it was inappropriate for me (as a non-Jewish person) to use names that seem familiar/intuitive to me. Lev is one of those; Chaya is not. For non-Jewish people more familiar than me with Kh and hard Ch sounds, maybe Chaya could be appropriate.

This message was edited 4/24/2025, 1:46 PM

It depends on the character. I knew a Turkish Muslim guy called Lev; in his case it was short for Levent. So that would work.Alona could work on other people; it looks vaguely trendy, like someone was getting creative with Alana or the word "alone" for a name.Chaya might work on a gentile African-American character. It reminds me of names like Inaya, Ayana and Kaia.
Alona might be, it's that close to Ilona or Alana.
Chaya and Lev, well, there would need to be some reason why non-Jewish people had those names, and explaining it would bog down the sstory. You could go with say, Kaia and Levi.
Lev is not exclusively Jewish.Chaya I think is only Jewish. Maybe Chara if you do not want Jewish association? Alona sound enough like trendy English it probably would work on non Jewish English speaking word people.