View Message

Caitlin or Rosie?
which is prettier?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Caitlin, pronounced Kaht-LEENI can't escape this hell, so many times I've tried...
vote up1
I prefer Caitlin despite its overuse. Rosie sounds too cutesy to me. I find Rose much prettier. It's a lot less popular than Caitlin if popularity is an issue for you.
vote up1
Not a huge fan of either, but overall Caitlin's better. Rosie's really stupid-sounding as a full name, and Rose's got to be one of my least favourite names, though everyone else here seems enamoured with it.
vote up1
Caitlinalthough, given the choice, I would pick Rose.
vote up1
I find Rosie far too cutesy. Rose is gorgeous. And Caitlin too.
vote up1
RosieThough I prefer Rosie as a nickname for something else, even Rose.
vote up1
This is a hard one. I personaly prefer Rosie as I don't really like the "Kate" sound (I prefer "Kat"), but then again I normally prefer names without the -ie ending. I do have a secret crush on the combo Annie Rose though ;-)
Both names are nice and I'd like to see them on a little girl.
vote up1
Rosie by far.
vote up1
Caitlin
vote up1
Caitlin may be wildly popular, but it's better than Rosie. Rosie reminds me of Rosie O'Donnell or Roseanne.
vote up1
Rose nn Rosie.
vote up1
Rose nn Rosie.
vote up1
Rose nn Rosie.
vote up1
Definitely Rosie. But if I really like Rosie I would use a longer name and use Rosie as a nickname. My favorite would be Rosalia or Rosalie. Or even Rosalind. Or even maybe 'Rose' with the nickname Rosie. Just to have a more professional looking full name instead of a nicknamey name.
vote up1
Rosie. I know too many Caitlins to think that is pretty.
vote up1
I think Rosie is prettier, but not as a full name.

This message was edited 6/19/2009, 9:52 AM

vote up1
Can I vote for Rosie, but as a nickname for something....like Rose, Rosa, Rosalie, Rosalia....
vote up1
I would say Caitlín, pronounced the Irish way, KAHT-leen. I love Caitlín. :) But I find the English pronunciation horrible. I don't know how a beautiful name like Caitlín has been mixed up with the awful Katelyn.Rosie's okay. I like it as a nickname for Rosalie and Rosaline.
vote up1