View Message

Peter Alexander or Benjamin Oliver?
Which of these do you prefer as a brother to Lionel Arthur and Tristan Micah?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

benjamin
vote up1
Both remind me of Beatrix Potter and both are pretty perfect. I think Peter fits the sibset best.
vote up1
I love both, but I think Peter Alexander wins out for me because I love Peter and it's more unusual than Benjamin. The flow isn't the best, but that doesn't actually matter much in real life. Peter, Lionel, and Tristan sound much better to me than Benjamin, Lionel, and Tristan. I'd expect Benjamin's brothers to be William and James or something much more common.
vote up1
Without rearranging, I would choose Benjamin Oliver, although my favorite combo is Alexander Benjamin. I don't care for Peter, but it does go with Lionel and Tristan.
vote up1
Benjamin Oliver is lovely! Benjamin Alexander is a great combo too, though I know you don’t want to rearrange.
vote up1
Peter Alexander. It sounds handsome and they goes well with each other.
vote up1
Benjamin Oliver is very handsome. Peter Alexander is a brand. Benjamin Alexander is a good combo too.
vote up1
Benjamin Oliver is nice.
vote up1
Peter as a FN, but with Benjamin as a MN instead of Alexander.
vote up1
Thanks; I’m not interesting in rearranging.
vote up2