Replies
I like Caleb better. I prefer its gentler sound.
Caleb
Caleb!
Jacob
No to both. I think the -b ending is not attractive to me. But from the nicknames, I prefer Jake (Jacob).
I love both, but Jacob is my favorite boys name (between Jacob and James).
I like them both equally, but if I had to choose it be Jacob as it's been a family name since the 17th century.