View Message

Clara or Calla?
Both my husband and I are stuck between Clara and Calla.
Which do you like best? And if you wouldn't mind saying why you like one more than the other (nothing to lengthy necessary , of course. :))
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Clara, no question. Sweet with a classic feel.:)
vote up1
ClaraClara is gorgeous and sophisticated and also simple and underused. Calla is also lovely but it feels trendy and a bit flimsy.
vote up1
Honestly, I don't love either but much prefer Clara because Calla reminds me of the word callous. I do like the nick, Callie, though.
vote up1
ClaraCalla's pretty and OK, but Clara has much more history and thus more substance and strength to me.
vote up1
Clara, because it sounds more complete. Calla seems very nicknamey sounding to me.
vote up1
CallaI just think it's prettier. It brings the smooth, elegant lines of the calla lily to mind. In comparison, Clara--a name I usually find quite pretty--sounds like a milkmaid.
vote up1
CallaI can't really say Clara properly so that's probably the main reason for me disliking the name. =/ I love Claire, though! I prefer the meaning and softer sound of Calla.
vote up1
Definitely Clara. I've loved it since I was a little girl (thanks to "The Nutcracker" and a book about the founder of the Red Cross, Clara Barton). I loved Calla for a while, and I still like it, but it has an almost trendy feel to it, and also might be mistaken for Kayla (in sound at least), which I REALLY don't like. BTW, I know a now teenage girl named Calla Elizabeth who has an older sister named Anja Maria. Their mom said Calla's name came from two places--Princess Calla from the "Gummi Bears" tv show and the song from "Mary Poppins" (super-calla-frajulistic...etc.; they used to call her Super Calla for that reason, lol).
vote up1
Clara hands down. Calla does not feel like a "real name" to me.
vote up1
Clara mCalla is too much like a guys name. Clara is feminine but not overbearingly and you can call her Claire!
vote up1
ClaraClara seems like a fuller more complete name. Calla while acceptable as a full name is kind of nicknamey. Clara would just age better.
vote up1
Calla
vote up1
Clara. It's simple and elegant. Calla is awkward sounding and sounds more like a nn to me.
vote up1
vote up1
That wasn't an option :-/
vote up1
Calla
vote up1
ClaraAlthough Calla is pretty, having a gardener for a mum has done certain things to my brain, one of which is that whenever I hear 'Calla', I have to add 'lily' on. Just one of those weird things! Clara, on the other hand, feels lovely and calm and English (also reminds me of Claire, one of my favourite names); I get the same feeling from it as I do from Beth. It also reminds me of the girl in 'Heidi' who Heidi teaches to walk again.
ETA: to clarify after reading another post regarding prn, I would only prn Clara 'KLAH-ra', as opposed to KLAIR-uh, which I don't like at all, despite sounding more like Claire. If you're pronounching it as the latter, then I like Calla better.

This message was edited 1/5/2008, 3:24 AM

vote up1
ClaraCalla makes my mouth feel weird when I say it. Clara is just pretty and has a really pleasant sound. Clara all the way!
vote up1
Clara, hands downDon't get me wrong, I love Calla, but only as a nn.
Clara is just more substantial on it's own than Calla is.
vote up1
I can live with either of them, though I feel Clara would probably age better. I am more inclined to actually say I like Calla more for it's general appeal.
vote up1
Calla reminds me of lilies and a cat and I think it sounds childish and unrefined. Clara is beautiful. It spans all generations while Calla does not. Calla also seems a lot like Callie and Kaylee and get grouped in with that feel for me, while Clara just epitomizes a sweet and sophisticated girl of any age.

This message was edited 1/5/2008, 1:05 AM

vote up1
Clara, no question ;)Although this does depend on how you are pronouncing it. I love the Clah-rah prn. but can't stand Clair-uh.Why? The sound just appeals more, and I love the meaning. Calla is nice too, but I much prefer Clara.
vote up1
Calla, no questionI think Calla is okay, it's grown on me. I don't like Clara at all (and Claire, Clare etc.), also it's a bit of a cow's name.
vote up1