View Message

Elizabeth. It's way more (consistently) popular than the others, at least where I live.

Bryony, definitely!! To a lesser extent, Juliette and Eve. If I was to revise the list:

---

Elizabeth
Briana
Juliet
Rosalie
Lucy
Evelyn
Matilda

Bryony. It looks too trendy. Briony might fit better.

If there's an odd girl out, it's Eve, since it's so simplistic compared to the others.

Matilda or Bryony.

yeah, definitely Bryony! I love this name, and it's on my PNL, but it doesn't go here because it doesn't have a classic vibe to it like the others.

Eve. It's very harsh and straightforward, and the rest of those names are more musical and/or frilly.

I feel that Bryony doesn't match. The others all seem more classic and have more historical usage.

Bryony has come into use as a name much more recently than any of the others

Bryony. The second would be Juliette and the third Rosalie. I like Bryony but it seems a bit trendy, is very dated in Britain and not timeless, resembles very common names that were popular in the 80s and 90s such as Brittany and Brianna and just seems like it doesn't belong with the others. Briony doesn't look so trendy but as Bryony is the original and looks better to me I would stick with that.

---

Juliette looks very French so it doesn't fit with classic English versions and Rosalie also has a bit of a French vibe. Rosemary and Juliet would fit better if that is your goal. I prefer Juliet over Juliette and like Rosalie and Rosemary about the same.

This message was edited 12/7/2016, 4:32 AM

Juliette, for its unnecessary French spelling. All the others are mainstream English.

Bryony, that's the only name on the list that doesn't have a classic feel to it. Juliet would also be much nicer than Juliette.

Bryony. Sounds modern and harsh and the other names sound classic, soft and beautiful

In my opinion Bryony sticks out like a sore thumb. Because it feels more like a modern name than the others. I think there might be a Pokemon character named Bryony.