I went to university with a student my age named
Donald "
Donnie" who was positively foxy. It definitely gave the name a serious bump for me. It's one thing if your parents or whatnot have nice, pleasant friends named
Don but another entirely when you see one that is seriously attractive and wasn't born in the 1950's. :-D
I don't love
Donald (or
Julius, but am totally on board with
Gordon and
Richard :-D) but I think it has more class than I've been used to allowing it. At worst it's a bit outdated to me, in the same way as
Ronald. Most Rons and Dons I've met have been the age of my parents, so I associate it with being dated to the same era as
Sharon,
Carol, etc. That's not bad necessarily but it's still a definite niche to me.
I actually prefer
Ron and
Don to
Ronald and
Donald. The -ald kind of drags them down to me. I could get more excited about
Donal, I think; it takes away the part that I'm iffy about plus gives it a nice long O sound. Between the two full names, though, I'm dead neutral.
That's a little rambley. :-) But overall I would probably rate it pleasant but not something I see as becoming my personal favorite.