View Message

I can’t choose between Helena and Lorelei
Which one is better? What do you think first when you hear these names?
Thanks in advance!
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I prefer Lorelei, and think of flower petals floating on river currents.
vote up1
I love Lorelei.
vote up1
I like Lorelei personally, it sounds softer and more youthful. Plus, I like the the mythological connotations. There’s a poem by Heinrich Hein about the Lorelei (can’t remember how the name is spelled in the poem, it might have been Lorelai) that I always liked, so I tend to think of that.Helena is alright. It makes me think of Helena Bonham Carter mostly, which is kind of cool, but I don’t really have any other associations for the name so it is kind of neutral to me.
vote up1
Heinrich Heine spells the Name Lore-Ley. Normally it's spelled Loreley in Germany. There are several poems (plus a rock and numerous ships) named Loreley in Germany
vote up2
Hey, thanks! I never knew that. I first read the poem in a junior high literature class. The text book must have translated the name too, maybe to make it more recognizable for English readers. I quite like the original spelling; I’ll have to make a note of it for the next time I read the poem!
vote up1
Helena, Lorelei is pretty but I can’t imagine it on a real person.
vote up1
Lorelei, it's prettier
vote up1
My first and last thoughts: Helen and Laura are much more to my taste. I would happily use either or both; I wouldn't consider Helena or Lorelei.
vote up1
For now Lorelei. I like the magical vibe it has and I think it sounds aesthetic. Helena on the other hand, is really beautiful, but I prefer Lorelei for now.
vote up1
Helena (heh-LEHN-na, heh-LAY-na). It's like Helen but doesn't seem as matronly (or as witty). Has a 'legendary' and elegant-powerful feeling, but is familiar enough that it is modest, to me.I don't care for Lorelei.

This message was edited 11/30/2022, 7:37 PM

vote up1
I’d go with Helena. It’s not really my type of name but it's safer than Lorelei.
I do like Lorelei better sound wise but I just can’t get over the meaning, and I feel like people would mispronounce it all the time. Although I suppose Helena has very irregular pronunciations even though it’s not necessarily difficult.
vote up1
Helena is better imo. It’s more timeless (if there is such a thing) and I prefer the meaning. It reminds me of Helen of Troy.Lorelei reminds me of Gilmore Girls (not necessarily bad but not the best either?).
vote up1
Lorelei is best in my opinion. Helena is nice but a bit stiff and unyielding.
vote up4
I prefere Helena.
Lorelei (rather Loreley) is a legendary figure - a very tragic story.
vote up1